Best Broadway Shows in New York September 2025

Q: What are the must-watch shows in New York this September?

Top picks include Operation Mincemeat, Maybe Happy Ending, Oh, Mary!, etc.

Q: How far in advance should I book tickets for September performances?

Plan to book 2–4 weeks ahead. Star-led shows (like Hamilton) and fall premieres sell quickly, especially around early September deals like Broadway Week. Booking early secures better seats and prices.

Best Broadway shows in September 2025

Box office tickets

Instantly confirmed to your phone

Choose your seats

The view you want, every time

Exclusive deals & discounts

Save big on New York's best shows

Book and relax

Trusted by NaN million guests and counting

Top shows

Shows in September

MUSICALS

4.7

(1,983)

The Lion King

from

$162

MUSICALS

4.6

(2,981)

Aladdin

from

$91.20

MUSICALS

4.9

(124)

The Great Gatsby

from

$76.50

MUSICALS

4.8

(144)

Hell's Kitchen

from

$56.40

MUSICALS

Buena Vista Social Club

from

$105.12

PLAYS

Stranger Things: The First Shadow

from

$91.50

MUSICALS

Maybe Happy Ending

from

$92.40

MUSICALS

Mamma Mia!

Opening on Aug 02, 2025

from

$81.12

Shows calendar

View calendar

New York in September 2025 at a glance

🌦️ Weather

Average high 25 °C (77 °F), low 16 °C (61 °F); low humidity, light jackets recommended.

👥 Crowds

Moderate—peak around Labor Day and UN General Assembly week.

🧳 What to carry

Layered clothing, light rain shell, portable charger, OMNY transit card.

🎉 Big events & festivals

Labor Day, West Indian Carnival, San Gennaro Festival, New York Fashion Week.

🗽 Labor Day month

Celebrate NYC’s Labor Day Parade alongside Broadway Week’s 2‑for‑1 ticket deals.

🌟 Must-see shows

Hamilton, The Great Gatsby, Hell's Kitchen, Operation Mincemeat

September brings crisp air and renewed energy to Broadway. With milder weather and the new season heating up, this month offers a diverse mix of Broadway musicals and September events. If you're searching for Broadway shows in September 2025, now’s the time—NYC’s theater district hums with fresh premieres and long-running hits.

Top Broadway shows in September 2025

Summer may fade, but Broadway surges in September. Here are the standout productions worth booking now.

Hamilton

Odom Jr. returns to play Aaron Burr in this 12‑week limited revival from Sept  9 to Nov 23, offering a new depth to the revolutionary classic.

Book now

Operation Mincemeat

This Olivier Award‑winning musical combines espionage, humor, and history in a World War II caper based on the real-life covert mission.

Book now

Hell’s Kitchen

A musical experience fueled by Alicia Keys’ powerhouse vocals and energetic choreography, delivering a behind‑the‑scenes dive into the world of culinary legends.

Book now

Top Broadway musicals in September 2025

A richer tapestry of Broadway musicals in September includes new hits and long‑running favorites—ideal for musical lovers seeking both depth and spectacle.

Maybe Happy Ending

Great for: Fans of sci‑fi fans & emotional musicals

Darren Criss and Helen J. Shen star as two retired helper‑bots in Seoul who rediscover connection and love in this Tony‑winning show

Book now

Buena Vista Social Club

Great for: Fans of Latin rhythms & energetic ensembles

A lively Cuban‑flavored musical, full of Latin rhythms and spirited ensemble performances.

Book now

The Great Gatsby

Great for: Fans of Jazz Age immersion & lavish visuals

A stylish Jazz Age revival packed with lavish sets and literary glamour.

Book now

Top Broadway plays in September 2025

Fall brings sharp new plays and comedic gems. Here are the top plays to book in September.

Oh, Mary!

Great for: Fans of sharp comedy, witty writing & contemporary themes

A Tony‑nominated work with fast‐paced humour and cultural commentary.

Book now

The Play That Goes Wrong

Great for: Slapstick lovers & fans of family entertainment

A hilarious disaster on stage that never disappoints.

Book now

Stranger Things: The First Shadow

Great for: Sci‑fi fans, Stranger Things followers & immersive staging

A thrilling prequel that brings Hawkins to the Broadway stage.

Book now

September premieres in New York

The city’s fall season begins with new openings and high-profile revivals. These Broadway September premieres are not to miss:

Art (Sept 16 at Music Box Theatre): A Tony-winning comedy revival starring James Corden, Bobby Cannavale, and Neil Patrick Harris in a crisp, sharply funny exploration of friendship and aesthetics.
Punch (Sept 29 at Samuel J. Friedman Theatre): James Graham’s riveting drama follows Jacob’s journey from guilt to redemption after a fatal incident, led by Will Harrison.
Waiting for Godot (Sept 28 at Hudson Theatre): Keanu Reeves and Alex Winter star in Samuel Beckett’s seminal absurdist masterpiece, directed by Olivier-award winner Jamie Lloyd

New York shows closing in September

If you're searching for final-chance Broadway shows in NYC in September, here’s what’s wrapping:

Gene & Gilda (Sept 7 at 59E59 Theater A): A one‑woman tribute exploring Gene Wilder and Gilda Radner’s romance, mixing humor and heartfelt stories.

Labor Day theme picks

September’s Labor Day weekend aligns with shows that spotlight American stories and cultural pride:

Hamilton – A revolutionary narrative about the founding fathers and the worker spirit.
Operation Mincemeat – Though set abroad, it celebrates Allied ingenuity and shared wartime legacy.
Oh, Mary! – A comedic take on everyday life that resonates with the working‑class narrative fitting a Labor Day theme.

Timeless Broadway shows to watch in September 2025

Looking for long‑running hits? These are solid choices this month while browsing Broadway shows in September.

Harry Potter and the Cursed Child

Magical extended run, spectacular effects, still fan‑favorite for families.

Book now

The Book of Mormon

Sharp comedic musical with cultural satire.

Book now

Chicago

Classic jazz-era musical with sharp choreography and timeless appeal.

Book now

The Lion King

Colorful and classic Disney spectacle perfect for all ages.

Book now

What’s on in New York in September

Kick off fall with vibrant citywide events—from Caribbean rhythms on Labor Day to Italian feasting in Little Italy.

West Indian American Day Carnival & J’Ouvert

A colorful Labor Day parade with steel‑pan music, costume floats, and Caribbean street food—NYC’s biggest cultural splash of the month.

📍 Where: Crown Heights, Brooklyn
⏱️ When: Monday, September 1

Feast of San Gennaro

Eleven days of Italian‑American tradition with street vendors, zeppole contests, live music, and a church procession.

📍 Where: Mulberry Street, Little Italy
⏱️ When: September 11–21

NYC Broadway Week

Score 2‑for‑1 Broadway ticket deals on over 20 shows during early September.

📍 Where: Theater District
⏱️ When: Tuesday, September 2 – Sunday, September 14

Pro tips for visiting New York in September

Dress smart for mixed temps. Early September sees 16 °C nights and 25 °C days. Layer light sweaters and carry a packable shell.
Use OMNY transit card. Expect subway crowds near Labor Day and UN Assembly—tap and go swiftly.
Prefer matinees mid‑week. Tuesday–Thursday double‑show days let you balance theatre and Midtown exploration.
Plan arriving early. Festivals like San Gennaro may slow street traffic—arrive 30 minutes before showtime.
Buy NYC Broadway Week deals. Two‑for‑one during early September can make premium seats accessible.
Bring portable charger. Digital tickets plus directions add up—stay powered throughout your outing.
Enjoy pre‑show neighborhood walks. Try Little Italy (San Gennaro) or Bryant Park for ambiance before curtain.
Stay hydrated on warm afternoons. While air‑conditioned indoors, outdoor walking still requires water.
Use TKTS strategically. Booth lines drop midday—grab day‑of discount tickets to long‑running musicals.
Check preview vs opening. If budget‑sensitive, previews of Punch or Godot offer early‑bird pricing.

Frequently asked questions about Broadway shows in September

What are the must-watch shows in New York this September?

Top picks include Operation Mincemeat, Maybe Happy Ending, Oh, Mary!, etc.

How far in advance should I book tickets for September performances?

Plan to book 2–4 weeks ahead. Star-led shows (like Hamilton) and fall premieres sell quickly, especially around early September deals like Broadway Week. Booking early secures better seats and prices.

What time should I book for shows if I'm touring New York during the day?

Opt for matinee shows on Tuesdays–Thursdays around 2 pm, which allow you to explore during the day—like museum visits or neighborhood strolls—then catch an evening performance at 7pm or 8pm. This split-day schedule balances sightseeing and entertainment.

Are there any shows recommended for first-time visitors to New York in September?

Yes—first-timers should consider iconic crowd-pleasers like The Lion King, Chicago, Wicked, or Aladdin. These shows offer big visuals, strong storytelling, and an unforgettable Broadway experience.

Is September good to visit New York for families or solo travellers?

Yes—September offers great weather (16–24 °C), fewer tourists as schools resume, and friendly settings for solo travel. Cultural events like parades and festivals make it ideal for both families and independent explorers.

Do ticket prices rise in September?

Premium shows may remain pricey, but NYC Broadway Week and TKTS offer 2‑for‑1 or discounted day seating.

What’s the weather like in September?

Expect highs around 25 °C (77 °F), lows near 16 °C (61 °F). Evenings feel crisp—light jackets work well.

How crowded is New York in September?

Moderate crowds prevail, though spikes occur around Labor Day and UN General Assembly.

Is Broadway Week worth attending?

Definitely. You get 2‑for‑1 offers in early September—use your OMNY card.

Any holiday closures or transport slowdowns?

Yes. Expect street closures and slow traffic in Midtown Manhattan from Sept 23–27 due to the UN General Assembly. Cars crawl under 4 mph, so take the subway, buses, ferry, bike, or walk instead.