English
English
2 hr 15 min with interval
Two Strangers (Carry a Cake Across New York)
DURATION
CLOSING DATE
Until July 6, 2026
AGE LIMIT
Suitable for 12+ yrs
AboutVenueTickets
Why watch Two Strangers (Carry a Cake Across New York)?
- A warm and witty rom-com musical with Olivier Award winner Sam Tutty and Christiani Pitts leading a story about an unexpected connection in New York City.
- After a successful Off West End premiere at the Kiln Theatre in 2023, the show arrives on Broadway with new energy from writers Jim Barne and Kit Buchan.
- Themes of family and chance meetings play out through imaginative staging that turns stacks of silver suitcases into the landmarks of New York.
- Critics celebrate its humor, candid emotion, and standout performances at the Longacre Theatre, making this feel-good musical a solid pick for your next Broadway night.
Two Strangers (Carry a Cake Across New York) pairs an endlessly hopeful British visitor with a sharp, guarded New Yorker for what should be a quick favor. One wedding cake later, they find themselves pulled through the neighborhoods, family tensions, and emotional blind spots of a single New York day. Written by Jim Barne and Kit Buchan, the musical stars Olivier Award winner Sam Tutty (Dear Evan Hansen) and Christiani Pitts (A Bronx Tale, King Kong), whose chemistry fueled the show’s acclaimed 2023 Off West End premiere at the Kiln Theatre. Under Tim Jackson’s direction and choreography, the story unfolds through witty songwriting and a clever suitcase-driven set that keeps the city constantly shifting around them.
Storyline
An optimistic Brit arrives in New York to meet the father he has never known and is paired with a blunt, practical New Yorker who would rather be anywhere else. A simple task involving a wedding cake sends them across the city where family tensions, unexpected honesty, and mismatched worldviews collide. Set in present day New York, the story explores connection, vulnerability, and how two strangers can change each other in one unpredictable day.
Show timings
Show timings for Two Strangers (Carry a Cake Across New York) may vary every week. You can check the show timings for your preferred date at the next stage of booking.
Cast & crew
- Leading roles: Sam Tutty as Dougal, Christiani Pitts as Robin
- Director: Tim Jackson
- Writer/Music/Lyrics: Jim Barne and Kit Buchan
- Choreographer: Tim Jackson
- Set/Costume Design: Soutra Gilmour
- Lighting Design: Jack Knowles
Note: Producers cannot guarantee the appearance of any particular artist, which is always subject to illness and holidays.
Top songs
With a score by Jim Barne and Kit Buchan, audiences can expect witty, heartfelt songs that capture the chaos and charm of New York City. While the full Broadway cast album is yet to be released, the musical’s original run featured standout numbers that blend humor, heart, and the thrill of new beginnings.
Age & content guide
- This show is suitable for ages 12 and above.
- Age suitability recommendations are just suggestions. So, trust your judgment when booking tickets for any show, and enjoy!
Longacre Theatre Read more
The Longacre Theatre is a Broadway gem, designed by Henry B. Herts and opened in 1913. Its French Neo-classical architecture and elegant interiors have hosted a diverse array of productions, from classic dramas to modern musicals. Over the years, it’s welcomed stars and hit shows, making it a beloved destination for theatergoers seeking both history and a touch of Broadway glamour.
The Longacre Theatre seating plan will help you find the best seats in the theater.
Getting there
- Address: 220 W 48th St, New York, NY 10036, United States
- Bike: There is a Citi Bike station on Broadway and West 48th Street.
- Bus: The nearest stops are on West 49th Street and 7th Avenue and West 49th Street and 8th Avenue, which cater to several lines including M50, M20 or M104.
- Subway: The closest station is on 49th Street, which serves the N, Q, R, and W lines, and is just a few minutes away from the theater.
Facilities & accessibility
Available facilities: restrooms, drinking water fountain
Accessibility: wheelchair accessible, access performances, companion seating
Additional information
- Security: To ensure your comfort and security, you might encounter a few security checks when you arrive at the venue.
- Dress code: Smart casual or semi-formal attire is the way to go.
- Outside food: While outside food isn't usually allowed, many theaters have cafes or restaurants nearby for you to check out before or after the show.
Tickets redemption
- You’ll get an instant email confirmation right after you book your tickets.
- Enjoy a hassle-free entrance to the venue by showing your mobile ticket and a valid photo ID – no printout necessary!
Cancellation & refunds
- Tickets cannot be refunded, amended, or rescheduled.
Frequently asked questions about Two Strangers (Carry a Cake Across New York)
What age group is Two Strangers (Carry a Cake Across New York) suitable for?
There is no strict age limit, but it is generally recommended for audiences aged 12 and above.
Where is the musical playing in New York?
It is running at the Longacre Theatre in New York.
What is the story about?
The plot follows an optimistic British visitor and a practical New Yorker who end up carrying a wedding cake across the city, leading to an unexpected day filled with humour, heart, and self-discovery.
How long does the performance run?
The running time is approximately 2 hours and 15 minutes, including one intermission.
Who are the main stars?
Sam Tutty leads the cast as Dougal, with Christiani Pitts starring as Robin.
What are the popular songs in the musical?
The score includes favourites such as “Say the Word,” “New York Is Yours,” and “What If It’s Me.” You can listen to the London production album here.
Is this musical suitable for first-time Broadway visitors?
Yes, it's a heartfelt story, modern humour, and accessible music make it a great choice for newcomers.